The Boyar Value Group’s 3rd Quarter Letter 2023
boyarvaluegroup.com · 2023-09-30 · tier T2
Source: Letter · boyarvaluegroup.com dated 2023-09-30. Auto-generated factual summary. Not investment advice. Verify before acting.
Boyar Asset Management's October 2023 letter reviews market performance and valuations following a difficult third quarter. The S&P 500 fell 3.3% in Q3 after gaining over 20% year-to-date, driven primarily by large technology stocks. The authors note the S&P 500 trades at 17.8x forward earnings—elevated by historical standards—while the top 10 stocks trade at 25.9x, representing 31.9% of the index, a multidecade high. Growth stocks remain expensive at 3.6 P/E points above their long-term average, while small-cap value trades 16% below its 20-year average. Small-caps face headwinds from rising rates and refinancing pressure, but historically outperform in post-recession periods. Bond losses have been severe, with long-duration bonds down 46–53% since March 2020. The authors emphasize long-term investing discipline, noting the S&P 500 has never posted a negative 20-year return since 1950.
Citations · 6
“Currently the stocks in the Russell 1000 growth index are selling 3.6 P/E multiple points higher than their long-term average (dating back to 1997), with value shares (represented by the Russell 1000 value index) selling slightly less than their long-term average.”
p#1 · confidence 95%
“Small-cap value sells 16% below its 20-year average P/E multiple, while large-cap growth shares are trading at 30% above their 20-year average P/E multiple”
p#1 · confidence 95%
“bonds maturing after 10 years or more have decreased by 46% since peaking in March 2020, and 30-year bonds have decreased by 53%. These declines eclipse the average bear market loss of 39% since the 1970s”
p#1 · confidence 95%
“The Russell 2000... has trailed the Russell 1000 (an index of larger companies' shares) by ~13% in 2023... currently ~28% below its 2021 high”
p#1 · confidence 95%
“since 1950, there has never been a 20-year period when investors did not average a gain of at least 6% per year in the stock market.”
p#1 · confidence 95%
“The S&P 500 declined 3.3% for the 3rd quarter... performance of the market-cap weighted S&P 500 index this year (+13.1% through Q3) has been driven primarily by large technology companies”
p#1 · confidence 95%
Follow this investor
Mark Boyar
More from Mark Boyar
Browse all →- Mark BoyarThe Boyar Value Group’s 1st Quarter Letter 2026
Letter
· 2026-Q1
Boyar Research sees value opportunities emerging as market leadership broadens beyond mega-cap stocks amid geopolitical shocks and AI uncertainty.
Original on boyarvaluegroup.com ↗2026-03-31
- Mark BoyarBoyar Value Group 2025 Year-End Review
Letter
· 2025-Q4
Boyar Research reviews 2025's volatile markets, finding discipline rewarded despite tariff shocks, narrow leadership, and mixed sentiment signals.
Original on boyarvaluegroup.com ↗2025-12-31
Summarized by DailySharpe AI